Pro bono survey: Brazil

27 nov 2015
Tamanho do texto

Brazil

The year 2015 marks a turning point for pro bono work in Brazil because the federal bar association (OAB) finally lifted restrictions that prevented law firms from providing legal advice to individuals on a pro bono basis. This relaxing of the rules has the power to fundamentally change the country’s pro bono culture, providing law firms rise to the challenge.

Because the ruling came in June this year and our survey is based on information from 2014, it’s too early to see how law firms are adapting from the survey alone – even though the rule was relaxed in 2013 after the OAB issued an injunction lifting the restrictions. But Marcos Fuchs, the director of the Instituto Pro Bono and a key campaigner for the change, is positive. He says firms are keen to prepare to take on cases for individuals by further institutionalising the practice. “We are receiving many, many calls from individuals, and lawyers are thinking about taking these cases… it’s a new era,” he says.

Because Brazilian firms have been banned from doing pro bono work for individuals (only firms in two states, one of which was São Paulo, were able to even provide free legal advice to NGOs), very few have implemented pro bono systems. Just one-fifth of firms among this year’s respondents have a pro bono coordinator, while around a third account for pro bono in lawyers’ salaries and provide training on it. The amount of pro bono work lawyers are doing appears to be largely consistent, with 43% of firms reporting they did more pro bono work in 2014 than 2013. This corresponds with the Instituto’s report. In 2014, the IPB provided free legal service to 54 NGOs and 113 individuals, which Fuchs says was an increase on 2013.

Hopefully, funding to the Instituto Pro Bono will also increase now firms are likely to benefit even more from the service it provides. Just seven out of 62 member law firms provide annual funding to the institute (the number increased by one in 2014), which is markedly lower than in countries with fully fledged systems.

Encouragingly, there was a notable increase in respondents from Brazil this year, who shared stories of interesting pro bono projects. Levy & Salomão Advogados has been providing legal advice to Equality Now in connection with a human trafficking case; Machado, Meyer, Sendacz e Opice Advogados is part of a regional group of firms working with the Thomson Reuters Foundation and housing charity Techo to produce a study on housing rights in the region; Siqueira Castro Advogados represents Brazil’s National Conference of Bishops before the Supreme Court in its fight to give Quilombolas communities legal ownership of the land they have lived on for many generations; and Demarest Advogados has provided the necessary legal support to a learning institute so it could distribute hearing devices to those in need across Brazil. 

 

  2014 2013
Average size of responding firm 148 lawyers
(Range: 2 to 1,022 lawyers)
152 lawyers
(Range: 2 to 943 lawyers)
PBDA signatories 26% 32%
Clearing house membership 52% 72%
Firms with PB coordinator 22% 47%
PB affects salary and advancement 30% 32%
PB treated as billable hours 36% –
PB included in training 35% 26%
PB work measured 40% 58%
Total PB hours completed in 2014 9% of firms completed more
than 1,000 hours
11% of firms completed more
than 1,000 hours
Average PB hours/lawyer in 2014 30% of firms averaged 10 to 29
pro bono hours in 2014; 
4% of firms averaged 30 hours or more
33% of firms averaged 10 to 29 pro bono
hours per lawyer in 2013
Comparison of 2014 and 2013 47% of firms did more
pro bono in 2014 than 2013
67% of firms did more pro

 

Autoria