Brazil anti-bribery act application a challenge

08 ago 2013
Tamanho do texto

Brazil’s new anti-bribery act– a law that for the first time instituted corporate criminal responsibility for acts of corruption — is considered an institutional advancement even though its application will be a challenge for attorneys and companies’ compliance departments. 

At a seminar in Sao Paulo on the new law on 8 August, Mariana de Araujo, an antitrust lawyer at Levy & Salomão, and Pierpaolo Bottini, a criminal attorney at Bottini & Tamasauskas, raised several issues in relation to the new act, the most important concerning the power to investigate violations — a responsibility bestowed on several agencies. 

Brazil’s Office of the Comptroller General will be the sole agency responsible for initiating international bribery proceedings, according to the lawyers. But when it comes to applying penalties such as the dissolution of a company or asset seizures, the court system will have to be used by public prosecutors or by lawyers at the affected government entities at the federal, state and municipal levels, according to Araujo. 

“Having a wide array of agents conducting an investigation and applying fines may spur diverse interpretations of what constitutes a violation and result in the application of non-uniform penalties,” Araujo said. 

However, considering Brazil’s new anti-bribery act “was inspired” by the country’s modernized 2012 antitrust code, it is a matter of time until the jurisprudence is consolidated. Over the years, fine calculation standards and sanctions imposed by the Administrative Council for Economic Defense (CADE) for antitrust violations should set precedents for corruption crimes as well, according to Araujo. 

“No law will ever come out of Congress being perfect. There is no panacea,” said the Levy & Salomão partner. The new anti-bribery act will take effect on 29 January 2014, or six months after President Dilma Rousseff signed the bill into law, Araujo added. 

Growing pains  

For his part, Pierpaolo Bottini agreed that application of the new anti-bribery act will be challenging, adding this reflects “Brazil’s growing pains as the country tries to improve its institutions”. 

The definition of corruption is “a lot broader” in the new anti-bribery act than in the country’s penal code, Bottini said, adding that he sees the possibility of federal prosecutors using provisions of the new act to accuse companies of money laundering and tax evasion, which may or may not be related offenses. 

As is the case with Brazil’s antitrust statute, companies may apply for a leniency program and get partial immunity. 

The program entitles corporations to reduce by up to two-thirds the value of fines for crimes of corruption, which will vary between 0.1% to 20% of an entity’s gross sales — or reach to up BRL 60m (USD 26m) if calculation of a fine is not possible. The company may also lose assets and be ineligible for public finance if convicted of bribery. 

However, a decision on whether to apply for leniency and cooperate with authorities remains one of the most delicate faced by a company, said Bottini. 

Weighing confessions 

Plea bargains exist in Brazilian law for individuals involved in corruption, but authorities may have little incentive to cut a deal with the manager of a company if the organization he or she represents has already submitted all evidence available as a leniency applicant. 

“The question is, what will the individual have to offer?,” said Bottini, adding provisions in Brazil’s antitrust law present the same dilemma. Sometimes a company wants to enter settlement talks (cease-and-desist agreements with CADE) but its manager is afraid of how that would affect himself or herself in the criminal sphere, Bottini said. 

“The safest thing is to apply for leniency and at the same time negotiate a plea bargain with prosecutors,” Bottini noted. 

Brazil’s Congress delayed approval of the country’s antitrust law for about six years, however, the anti-bribery bill, introduced by the government in 2010, moved through the system much more quickly. The speed was partially due to street protests that swept the nation in June. At the public acts, protestors expressed dissatisfaction with various problems ranging from Brazil’s poor infrastructure to corruption and the cost of stadiums for the 2014 World Cup.